Maybe Cafeteria Catholicism Isn't So Twentieth Century, After All...

"Heretics are heretics and bear the name, because out of the articles of faith they choose at their taste and pleasure those which it seems good to them to believe, rejecting and denying the others. And Catholics are Catholics, because without any choice or election they embrace, with an equal assurance and without exception, all the faith of the Church."
~ St. Francis de Sales 1567-1622 (!)